Reset Password

A Taste of Paradise: Must-Try Dishes on Anna Maria Island


Anna Maria Island isn’t just a beach bum’s paradise; it’s a haven for foodies too! Fresh, local seafood reigns supreme, but there are hidden gems and international flavors waiting to be explored. Here’s a dive into the island’s most famous dishes you simply can’t miss:

1. Fish Tacos: A Beachside Staple

Florida beaches and fish tacos go hand in hand, and Anna Maria Island does them right. The Waterfront Restaurant offers a unique twist on the classic with their grouper tacos. Huge chunks of perfectly cooked grouper are nestled in warm tortillas and topped with a surprising sesame ginger sauce for an Asian-inspired explosion of flavor.

2. Bouillabaisse: A French Kiss on the Gulf Coast

Looking for a fine-dining experience? Then look no further than the exquisite bouillabaisse at The Beach House Restaurant. This Provençal seafood stew is a symphony of flavors, featuring local fish, shellfish, and aromatic herbs simmered in a rich broth. It’s a true taste of the French Riviera, right here on Anna Maria Island.

3. Stone Crab Claws: A Seasonal Delicacy

A Florida specialty, stone crab claws are a must-try for seafood lovers visiting between October and May. These sweet and succulent claws are typically served simply with mustard sauce for dipping. Head to Rod & Reel Pier for a quintessential Florida experience – fresh stone crab claws enjoyed on a pier overlooking the turquoise waters.

4. Authentic Mexican: A Fiesta for the Senses

For a taste of Mexico, look no further than Poppo’s Taqueria. This vibrant spot uses fresh, local ingredients to create authentic dishes like tacos, burritos, and quesadillas. Their commitment to sustainability means you can feel good about indulging in their delicious and creative menu.

5. Key Lime Pie: A Sunshine State Classic

No Florida trip is complete without savoring a slice of Key lime pie. This iconic dessert features a tart and tangy lime filling nestled in a buttery graham cracker crust. The Sandbar Restaurant, housed in a historic building, offers a classic version that’s the perfect way to end a delicious island adventure.

Cinnamon Rolls fit for Royalty

While not exactly a local dish, Ginny’s and Jane E’s Café boasts legendary cinnamon rolls that are worth a mention. These gooey, giant pastries are the perfect way to start your day and will fuel your island explorations.

So, what are you waiting for? Dive into the culinary delights of Anna Maria Island and savor the taste of paradise! Also, don’t forget to book your stay at our rentals for the perfect stay after a tummy full of food!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.